All categories/Coffee/Coffee makers/Breville/Breville Precision Brewer
Breville Precision Brewer

Breville Precision Brewer

Based on 104 comments across 3 communities
TL;DR
Owners agree the Precision Brewer makes excellent, customizable batch coffee and is solidly built, but it skews negative in real-world use. The dominant complaint by far is the thermal carafe lid: the flap sticks and overflows coffee onto the counter, and water trapped in the sealed lid grows mold that owners can only fix with a DIY drill-hole mod. Many also report weak, watery, or lukewarm results on smaller batches.

27% of 104 verified owners recommend the Breville Precision Brewer.

What 104 owners say
419 comments reviewed · scored on the 104 clearest verdicts
27%
Recommend
28 owners
15%
Neutral
16 owners
58%
Don't recommend
60 owners
Last 6 months:25% recommend(16 recent verdicts)→ holding steady vs older reviews
Source
Score
N
Counted in the score
Reddit
27%
101
Other forums
33%
3
Reviewed, but not counted — and why
Affiliate blogsipaid commission
100%
3

Affiliate blogs here say 100% recommend, while the owner-based score is 27%. They earn a commission on every sale — so we show them for transparency but never let them move the score.

The headline score reflects owners (Reddit, enthusiast forums), independent lab tests, and blogs with no affiliate links. YouTube and affiliate blogs are shown for perspective but kept out — hover the i for why.

What owners like
  • Excellent batch-brew quality, makes great-tasting full pots · 12 · 12%
  • Customizable bloom, temp, and flow controls (SCA-certified flexibility) · 7 · 7%
  • Solid, well-built machine that holds up over years · 5 · 5%
  • Convenient set-it-and-forget-it brewing for groups · 4 · 4%
  • Thermal carafe keeps a full pot hot well · 3 · 3%
What owners flag
  • Thermal carafe lid flap sticks and overflows coffee onto the counter · 20 · 19%
  • Water gets trapped in the sealed lid and grows mold · 12 · 12%
  • Coffee comes out weak, watery, and under-extracted, especially small batches · 11 · 11%
  • Lukewarm, inconsistent water temperature on small batches · 7 · 7%
  • Uneven extraction from the small shower head leaves bitter or sour cups · 7 · 7%

Top quotes, sourced

419 reviewed · 107 shown
Sentiment
Community
Sort
r/pourover— neutral

if easy morning batch brewing and reliability are more important, I would go with the Sage/Breville Precision Brewer. You can get consistent flavor and results with either machine.

r/pourover▲ recommend

I don’t see enough people talking about this trusty little machine. I personally brew large batches of coffee (60g/ 1 litre) every morning with this thing and have got plenty of pleasant cups.

r/Coffee▼ don’t recommend

Caraffe lid defective. 1. Sporadically, coffee sprays out during brewing all over the counter! 2. Water held inside lid. 3. Can’t pour coffee out through the bad lid. Just dribbles out.

r/JamesHoffmann— neutral

I've had the American model for about a year now and love it. I will say though, I feel like I am constantly tinkering with the 'My Brew' settings to sort of find that perfect combination.

r/Coffee▼ don’t recommend

I have to keep a very close eye on the coffee canister when I put paper filters. The steam from the machine folds to the top of the coffee bed it AT LEAST 5 out of 10 times I do coffee.

r/Coffee▲ recommend

I’m very pleased with the Breville Precision Brewer. The bloom time and water flow speed controls allow me to reasonably mimic what we can do on our Fetco at the cafe, which I think rivals manual brewing.

r/pourover— neutral

For big batches it’s great. Hate it for any small batches. Has some heating issues with small batches with personal testing but makes really awesome cups for a full pot.

r/pourover▼ don’t recommend

It gave me decent cups, but ultimately pulled the trigger on the Aiden when that launched. Been much happier with my results from the Aiden that anything I was able to get from the Breville

r/Coffee▲ recommend

I much prefer the results out of the Breville. I also enjoy the ability to change variables on the Breville which makes the result even better.

r/BrevilleCoffee▼ don’t recommend

For me it’s an issue with the spring loaded topper to the carafe. The thing gets stuck in the down position, then it doesn’t lift up the little thing on the coffee maker.

r/Coffee▲ recommend

I have it, and I like it. I don’t find the pump to be that bad. I certainly haven’t had issues of mugs sliding around. I did have a QA issue with the first one. I pulled it out of the box and a chunk of plastic was broken off the water tank.

r/Coffee— neutral

I can't say that I have noticed either setting having significant variations, at least nowhere near as different as changes in grind size.

r/Coffee▼ don’t recommend

the Breville shower head only drips water in the center, leading to uneven extraction. There is most likely a crater in the grounds bed after brewing. This is the main drawback to this coffee maker.

r/Coffee— neutral

I had issues with the bloom dumping half a tank of water (way too much to simply bloom) So I contacted Breville. They said that shouldn

r/Coffee▲ recommend

I have a precision. I mostly make it in 4-6 cup brews (which makes 2-3 cups I drink) and it works great in my opinion.

r/pourover▼ don’t recommend

One reason I dislike drip machines is they are hard to keep clean, and have to be descaled, but they also just don’t make as good coffee, even the best ones.

Foodal (affiliate)▲ recommend

the features list for both models justifies the higher cost than what you’ll find with your run-of-the-mill appliance. Yes, it’s JUST a coffee maker, but it’s also one of the few to earn certification by the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA).

r/BrevilleCoffee— neutral

Now, having bought a used one,I can say it apparently does not. I set my Bloom to one minute and put my pot in at about 45 seconds.

Home-Barista— neutral

my coffee comes out weak and underextracted. If I brew a large amount using the flat bottom filter, it comes out great.

r/Coffee▲ recommend

for large batches of medium roast please all coffee, its great. we really have it dialed in for our local roast.

r/BrevilleCoffee▼ don’t recommend

by Mar we were tired of cleaning the countertop and inside the lower cabinets from coffee spills which were occurring at least three or four times a week.

r/pourover— neutral

Having to manually intervene to ensure that the bed gets evenly saturated is very 2010. Tank of a machine

r/Coffee▲ recommend

have enjoyed it as a good alternative for when I’m too lazy to manual pour or when I have a lot of guests over

r/Coffee▼ don’t recommend

I started suspecting a moldy taste. After finding this thread and doing the drill hole mod and soaking in cleaning solution heaps of gross stuff came out.

Showing 124 of 107