1
Igloo BMX 52 QT
Most owners of the Igloo BMX 52 Qt are satisfied, praising its 3-5+ day ice retention even in 80-90°F heat and its much lower price than premium coolers like Yeti or RTIC. A popular owner move is adding a DIY gasket or self-adhesive weatherstripping to the lid, which several report noticeably tightens the seal and stretches ice life even further. A meaningful minority pushes back, though, pointing to the lack of a factory lid gasket that lets water leak out when the cooler tips, hinges that crack or pull loose from the plastic body, and a general sense from a few buyers that the build feels cheap or entry-level for the price.
89%
18
2
Coleman Xtreme 5-Day 50 QT Cooler
Owners rave that it holds ice for days and rivals a Yeti at a fraction of the cost, though real-world retention depends on pre-chilling and block ice, and the latch-less lid, handles, and hinges feel cheap.
89%
226
3
YETI Tundra 45
Owners overwhelmingly praise the Tundra 45 for multi-day ice retention, with many getting 4-5 days and some a full week while camping, plus a rugged build that survives years of rough use. The most common complaints are that it isn't airtight and will leak if laid on its side, and that a few owners found cheaper coolers held ice just as long. It's a pricey, somewhat heavy cooler, but most feel it earns its reputation as a long-haul, buy-it-for-life choice.
77%
48
4
YETI Roadie 24
Owners overwhelmingly praise the Roadie 24 for its excellent ice retention and rugged, compact build that fits easily in a vehicle and works well for one or two people on day or weekend trips. The common gripes are its weight when fully loaded, the premium price, and the lack of a drain plug paired with a handle some find awkward. A handful of buyers also received units with scratches or dents, and several note it runs small for feeding a group or packing several days of food.
76%
82
5
RTIC 45 QT Hard Cooler
Owners overwhelmingly praise this cooler's ice retention, with multiple owners reporting it keeps drinks and food cold for a full day at the beach or even several days on a single bag of ice. Several also see it as a strong value pick, calling it a better buy than Yeti for less money. A smaller minority ran into problems, including one owner whose lid seal leaked and had to be returned, and another who felt the price was still too high for what you get. A few also noted practical limits, like the 45-quart size filling up fast once ice is added, leaving little room for anything but a six-pack.
67%
12
6
YETI Roadie 48 Wheeled Cooler
The Roadie 48 earns real praise for its ice retention and one-person rolling, and owners who do mostly car-accessible trips tend to be happy with it. But it is a heavy, premium cooler that some reach for only on longer outings, and the wheels lose their value on soft sand. Whether it is worth the price comes down to how often you actually need to roll a big cooler.
57%
7
