All categories/Kitchen/Dutch Ovens/Lodge/Lodge 5-Quart Cast Iron Double Dutch Oven
Lodge 5-Quart Cast Iron Double Dutch Oven

Lodge 5-Quart Cast Iron Double Dutch Oven

Based on 105 comments across 3 communities
TL;DR
Owners love this double Dutch oven most for its versatility, since the flat, knobless lid works as its own skillet and lets you bake bread on the shallow side instead of lowering dough into a screaming-hot deep pot. It's bare cast iron with no enamel to chip, holds heat well, and is widely praised as a bargain that handles chili, roasts, frying, and more. The recurring gripes: it's heavy with hard-to-grip handles, the bare iron needs seasoning upkeep, and high-temp bread bakes or trapped water can wear that seasoning down.

88% of 105 verified owners recommend the Lodge 5-Quart Cast Iron Double Dutch Oven.

What 105 owners sayⓘ 10% link it — looks organic
930 comments reviewed · scored on the 105 clearest verdicts
88%
Recommend
92 owners
5%
Neutral
6 owners
7%
Don't recommend
7 owners
Source
Score
N
Counted in the score
Reddit
88%
104
Independent blogsino affiliate links
100%
1
Reviewed, but not counted — and why
Affiliate blogsipaid commission
50%
2

Affiliate blogs here say 50% recommend, while the owner-based score is 88%. They earn a commission on every sale — so we show them for transparency but never let them move the score.

The headline score reflects owners (Reddit, enthusiast forums), independent lab tests, and blogs with no affiliate links. YouTube and affiliate blogs are shown for perspective but kept out — hover the i for why.

What owners like
  • Lid doubles as a separate skillet or pan, making it remarkably versatile · 42 · 40%
  • Flat, low lid makes loading bread dough far easier with fewer burned hands · 28 · 27%
  • Handles plenty beyond bread, from chili and roasts to soups and frying · 18 · 17%
  • Excellent value, often around $50 · 16 · 15%
  • Bare cast iron holds heat well and browns nicely, with no enamel to crack or chip · 12 · 11%
What owners flag
  • Heavy and rough cast finish · 4 · 4%
  • High-temp bread preheats can smoke and burn off the seasoning · 4 · 4%
  • Bare iron needs seasoning upkeep, and trapped water between the pieces erodes it · 3 · 3%
  • Can arrive with rancid factory oil or surface rust to clean off · 3 · 3%
  • Short side handles are hard to grip, even with gloves · 2 · 2%

Top quotes, sourced

930 reviewed · 108 shown
Sentiment
Community
Sort
Reddit▼ don’t recommend

I have suspected for a while now that the crust was developing to quickly in my usual baking vessel (a 5qt lodge double Dutch oven).

Reddit▲ recommend

Currently I’m using the lodge double oven. I use the lid and the pot as a bread dome by baking with it upside down. It is not enameled and has more uses than the bread dome since I can also use the pot as a Dutch oven.

Reddit— neutral

Just got a lodge double Dutch oven and a bit disappointed realizing I’ll be mostly limited to boules with it - but it was like 1/5th the price

Reddit— neutral

I have a regular enamel cast iron Lodge Dutch Oven and the Double Dutch Oven. We use the regular enamel cast iron way more- a couple of times a week. The double dutch oven is great for camping and thats primarily how we use it.

Reddit▲ recommend

was my number one recommendation. I've got two at home. The lid doubles as a skillet, so it can be used as the lid or base.

Reddit▼ don’t recommend

My lodge double Dutch oven I have to oven season every time I cook anything that has water in the pot because hot water evaporates gets stuck between where the two metals meet and erodes the seasoning

Reddit▼ don’t recommend

I’ve got the lodge double Dutch, which has the shallow pan as a lid and can be used upside down like the bread oven) and whenever I try to use it for bread the high-temp preheat smokes and burns all my seasoning.

Reddit⚠ product link— neutral

I've had [this one](https://www.walmart.com/ip/Lodge-Cast-Iron-5-Quart-Seasoned-Double-Dutch-Oven/12554407?wmlspartner=wlpa&selectedSellerId=0) for a decade or so. Only difference is the handle on the lid/top pan. I actually much prefer mine; I wouldn't want that handle.

Reddit▲ recommend

The Lodge double dutch oven is fantastic and only $50US. It's so good, though, that my wife claimed the "skillet" side for everyday cooking

Reddit▼ don’t recommend

I just got a Lodge Double Dutch Oven. I boiled water and vinegar to get rid of the oil and still it has a TON of rancid oil. I heated it in the oven at 450degrees for an hour and a good amount of rust still on it. Used salt to get rust out. But still rust on it and rancid oil. It is a heavy pain!

Reddit— neutral

I throw a pizza stone one rack under the dutch oven when I put the dough in the preheated dutch oven. It keeps the bottom of the bread from burning.

Reddit▲ recommend

I ended up getting a lodge Dutch oven like this one: https://www.lodgecastiron.com/product/double-dutch-oven?sku=L8DD3 No real cleanup like the le creuset and I’ve also used it for sourdough bread. The top is also a pan which I use regularly by itself. It’s perfect for over the top chili.

Reddit— neutral

I personally have a Lodge Cast Iron, but would like a ceramic or other material, the steam from adding ice cubes to the pot is causing rust

Reddit▲ recommend

If you buy the Lodge Double Dutch oven you can bake the bread in the lid and lower the “bottom” on top.

Reddit⚠ affiliate link · not counted▼ don’t recommend

I finally am concluding that the Lodge doesn't allow for as much rise or spring.

Reddit▲ recommend

My husband got me a Lodge Double Dutch Oven right quick - not to let a week go by. The Lodge CI works really well for bread.

Reddit▼ don’t recommend

I know everyone loves Lodge, and I have one of their cast iron cookers which works well, but I'd trade in a heartbeat for the BK or the RO. It's SO freaking heavy

Reddit— neutral

I found that from mainly just doing sourdough I have to retouch the seasoning almost every use

Reddit▼ don’t recommend

mine unfortunately has a hole, probably caused by a small bubble during the pouring

HotCooking (affiliate)— neutral

It's difficult to get your fingers into the handles, with or without gloves.

Reddit⚠ product link▲ recommend

I bought three of these about 5 years ago, when they were cheaper than $50 each, but they work great

Reddit▲ recommend

I started off with two Lodge double Dutch ovens. Then was gifted two Challenger bread pans. I like both

Reddit▼ don’t recommend

The lodge 5qt is 5.6kg / 12.5 lbs. that’s really heavy!

Reddit▲ recommend

I'm using the Lodge dutch oven where the "lid" doubles as a fry pan. I use it as my base and then carefully lift the "pot" side on top. So effectively I'm baking it in an inverted fashion, but it makes it a lot easier to put the dough in and remove it without burning my arms.

Showing 124 of 108