Lodge 5-Quart Cast Iron Double Dutch Oven · problems & reliability report

Lodge 5-Quart Cast Iron Double Dutch Oven problems: what real owners report

7% of 105 verified Lodge 5-Quart Cast Iron Double Dutch Ovenowners don't recommend it — based on real owner comments from Reddit, enthusiast forums, and YouTube.

For balance: 90% recommend it. This page collects the complaints so you know what you're signing up for — read the full owner report for both sides. How we score

Most common complaints

In owners' own words

“I have suspected for a while now that the crust was developing to quickly in my usual baking vessel (a 5qt lodge double Dutch oven).”
— _DoppioEspresso_ on Reddit
“My lodge double Dutch oven I have to oven season every time I cook anything that has water in the pot because hot water evaporates gets stuck between where the two metals meet and erodes the seasoning”
— UpperFerret on Reddit
“I’ve got the lodge double Dutch, which has the shallow pan as a lid and can be used upside down like the bread oven) and whenever I try to use it for bread the high-temp preheat smokes and burns all my seasoning.”
— TheRealFiremonkey on Reddit
“I bought this one and i hate it so much i bought the camp oven lid to replace it.”
— @user-du1qf2mp9g on YouTube
“I just got a Lodge Double Dutch Oven. I boiled water and vinegar to get rid of the oil and still it has a TON of rancid oil. I heated it in the oven at 450degrees for an hour and a good amount of rust still on it. Used salt to get rust out. But still rust on it and rancid oil. It is a heavy pain!”
— BlackPriestOfSatan on Reddit
“I finally am concluding that the Lodge doesn't allow for as much rise or spring.”
— BlueWomba on Reddit
“I know everyone loves Lodge, and I have one of their cast iron cookers which works well, but I'd trade in a heartbeat for the BK or the RO. It's SO freaking heavy”
— Crazy-4-Conures on Reddit
“mine unfortunately has a hole, probably caused by a small bubble during the pouring”
— Life1989 on Reddit
“The lodge 5qt is 5.6kg / 12.5 lbs. that’s really heavy!”
— snugamate on Reddit

Setup quirks & things to watch for

Not complaints — practical notes from owners that didn't affect the score.

“I throw a pizza stone one rack under the dutch oven when I put the dough in the preheated dutch oven. It keeps the bottom of the bread from burning.”
— NukeCode87 on Reddit
“I found that from mainly just doing sourdough I have to retouch the seasoning almost every use”
— cherrycoke_yummy on Reddit
“I’ve been doing 600g in the 5qt double dutch”
— UseWhatName on Reddit
Weighing it up? The full report has the other side — what 90% of owners like about it, who it's for, and every sourced quote. Full Lodge 5-Quart Cast Iron Double Dutch Oven owner report →