Over-Ear Headphones · owner-verdict comparison

Apple AirPods Max 2 vs ATH-R70xa: what real owners say

Real owners lean toward the ATH-R70xa: 65% of 26 owners recommend it, vs 53% of 196 for the Apple AirPods Max 2.

Verdicts aggregated from Reddit, enthusiast forums, and YouTube owner comments — affiliate reviews excluded. Sample sizes differ; judge accordingly. How we score

Apple AirPods Max 2

53%of 196 owners recommend
53% recommend · 19% neutral · 28% don't
Owners praise
  • Rich, clear sound, the reason owners who keep it give most often
  • Strong noise cancelling, one of the features owners praise most
  • Comfortable for many owners, some for whole flights or workdays, though about as many find it too heavy
Owners complain about
  • Faults reported by many owners, mainly battery drain while sitting in the case and dropped connections, with several needing resets or a replacement unit
  • Heavy for many owners, some of whom get sore heads or headaches within an hour or two
  • Most first-generation owners who upgraded hear only small gains, though a smaller group calls it a clear step up
Full owner report →

ATH-R70xa

65%of 26 owners recommend
65% recommend · 27% neutral · 8% don't
Owners praise
  • Exceptionally light and comfortable for long listening sessions, staying cool even after hours of wear
  • Standout imaging and detail retrieval that owners call incredible or best-in-class for the price
  • Preferred over Sennheiser rivals like the HD600, HD6XX, and HD660S2, with more bass and dynamism
Owners complain about
  • Stock earpads run thin and can feel tight or press against the head, pushing many owners to swap in aftermarket R70X Refine pads for comfort
  • Treble and vocal timbre can sound artificial, thin, or divisive, especially on spoken content like YouTube videos
  • Mids sound recessed or pulled back, with measurements showing a dip around 300-400 Hz compared to headphones like the HD600
Full owner report →

Which should you buy?

Get the Apple AirPods Max 2 if
  • ✓Apple users who value tight integration with their devices and can exchange a faulty unit
  • ✓Listeners who want strong noise cancelling paired with full, detailed sound
  • ✓Buyers who can try them on and return them if the fit is wrong
Skip it if
  • Anyone sensitive to heavy headphones, especially for long sessions
  • First-generation Max owners hoping for a big jump in sound
Get the ATH-R70xa if
  • ✓Long listening sessions where light weight and all-day comfort matter most
  • ✓Gamers and daily drivers wanting sharp imaging and a fun, dynamic sound
  • ✓HD600/6XX owners wanting more treble energy, bass, and less recessed mids
  • ✓Warm-climate or long-session users who need cans that never run hot
Skip it if
  • Listeners wanting a neutral, analytical reference sound over a brighter V-shaped tuning
  • Anyone needing thick, plush stock earpads without buying aftermarket Refine pads

What Apple AirPods Max 2 owners say

“My AirPods Max 2 are pretty good and little bit better than AirPods Pro 3 in terms of ANC.”
— @AdityaBandaru13 on YouTube
“I bought a pair of these on a whim and couldn't be happier. I had resisted because a friend said they were uncomfortable. I actually find them comfortable and the noise cancelation is insane.”
— @jimtipton8888 on YouTube
“Just got my AirPods Max 2 yesterday and I’m already experiencing a massive battery drain.”
— @KevinHouseyutiol on YouTube

What ATH-R70xa owners say

“I listened to a bunch of highly rated headphones at the last CanJam in NYC and none of them made me want to upgrade from the R70xa.”
— this_is_me_drunk on Reddit
“I got the r70xa as well, but had to get a new amp to give it more juice to make it sing. But man, being so light i hardly reach for my other cans now and using these as daily drivers.”
— Waste_Search2125 on Reddit
“it has this really arfticial, unnatural sound to it that's neither analytic nor is it a smooth, rich entertaining sound”
— Overall-Cupcake7073 on Reddit

Apple AirPods Max 2 vs ATH-R70xa: frequently asked questions

Is the Apple AirPods Max 2 or the ATH-R70xa better?

Real owners lean toward the ATH-R70xa: 65% of 26 owners recommend it, vs 53% of 196 for the Apple AirPods Max 2.

Who should get the Apple AirPods Max 2?

Owners point the Apple AirPods Max 2 at apple users who value tight integration with their devices and can exchange a faulty unit, and listeners who want strong noise cancelling paired with full, detailed sound.

Who should get the ATH-R70xa?

Owners point the ATH-R70xa at long listening sessions where light weight and all-day comfort matter most, and gamers and daily drivers wanting sharp imaging and a fun, dynamic sound.

What do owners complain about?

The most-cited downside of the Apple AirPods Max 2 is faults reported by many owners, mainly battery drain while sitting in the case and dropped connections, with several needing resets or a replacement unit. For the ATH-R70xa, it's stock earpads run thin and can feel tight or press against the head, pushing many owners to swap in aftermarket R70X Refine pads for comfort.