Guitar Pedals · owner-verdict comparison

Electro-Harmonix Soul Food vs MXR Carbon Copy: what real owners say

Real owners rate these about evenly: 72% of 61 Electro-Harmonix Soul Food owners recommend it, vs 71% of 31 for the MXR Carbon Copy.

Verdicts aggregated from Reddit, enthusiast forums, and YouTube owner comments — affiliate reviews excluded. Sample sizes differ; judge accordingly. How we score

Electro-Harmonix Soul Food

72%of 61 owners recommend
72% recommend · 15% neutral · 13% don't
Owners praise
  • Widely trusted as an always-on clean boost and gain stage
  • Stacks well in front of tube screamers, SD-1s, OCDs and fuzzes, adding definition instead of mud
  • Loud, with a drive range owners find musical and easy to keep subtle
Owners complain about
  • A mid-forward color, described as honk or boxiness, that fights the amp's own voice and thins single coils as the drive comes up
  • Divisive as a standalone overdrive, with several owners using it only as a boost or taking it off the board
  • Hardware gripes vary unit to unit: hiss, a loud pop on switching, and one that would not pass signal in bypass
Full owner report →

MXR Carbon Copy

71%of 31 owners recommend
71% recommend · 13% neutral · 16% don't
Owners praise
  • Warm, natural-sounding analog delay tone that owners rank among the best analog delays available
  • Long-term reliability and loyalty, owners keep it for a decade or more, tour heavily with it, and keep returning to it after trying other delays
  • Underwhelming compared to alternatives for a minority of owners, some felt it didn't outperform other delays (like the analog settings on an FB/FB4) and ended up returning or replacing it
Owners complain about
  • Underwhelming compared to alternatives for a minority of owners, some felt it didn't outperform other delays (like the analog settings on an FB/FB4) and ended up returning or replacing it
Full owner report →

Which should you buy?

Get the Electro-Harmonix Soul Food if
  • ✓Players who want an always-on gain stage sitting under their main drive
  • ✓Anyone stacking overdrives or fuzzes and looking for a lead push with more definition
  • ✓Blues rock and humbucker players who want subtle grit that roars when the drive is cranked
  • ✓First klon-style pedal for someone curious about the circuit without boutique money
Skip it if
  • Players who want a boost that leaves the amp's midrange untouched
  • Single-coil strat players who need the low end intact at higher drive settings
Get the MXR Carbon Copy if
  • ✓Players wanting warm, natural analog delay
  • ✓Guitarists after slapback and short echo settings
  • ✓Ambient players needing swells that preserve the dry signal
  • ✓Beginners who want simple, hands-on controls
Skip it if
  • Players needing versatility beyond one analog sound
  • Those wanting very long delay times

What Electro-Harmonix Soul Food owners say

“This pedal really shines when you stack it with something like a tube screamer or OCD. It produces this super “chewy” (best way I can describe it) sound that I love. Great pedal”
— BackcountryAZ on Reddit
“It’s a great pedal especially for that price. Nice lead boost tone.”
— DuckDouble2690 on Reddit
“Sounds great but I could not tame the loud click it made turning on and off. Tried a bunch of recommendations but nothing worked.”
— Shirtarm on Reddit

What MXR Carbon Copy owners say

“Easily my favourite delay pedal!”
— @thejosebatista on YouTube
“Love the CarbonCopy.”
— @northof50now on YouTube
“j'ai acheté cet effet c'est loin d'être ça !”
— @francoisb4830 on YouTube

Electro-Harmonix Soul Food vs MXR Carbon Copy: frequently asked questions

Is the Electro-Harmonix Soul Food or the MXR Carbon Copy better?

Real owners rate these about evenly: 72% of 61 Electro-Harmonix Soul Food owners recommend it, vs 71% of 31 for the MXR Carbon Copy.

Who should get the Electro-Harmonix Soul Food?

Owners point the Electro-Harmonix Soul Food at players who want an always-on gain stage sitting under their main drive, and anyone stacking overdrives or fuzzes and looking for a lead push with more definition.

Who should get the MXR Carbon Copy?

Owners point the MXR Carbon Copy at players wanting warm, natural analog delay, and guitarists after slapback and short echo settings.

What do owners complain about?

The most-cited downside of the Electro-Harmonix Soul Food is a mid-forward color, described as honk or boxiness, that fights the amp's own voice and thins single coils as the drive comes up. For the MXR Carbon Copy, it's underwhelming compared to alternatives for a minority of owners, some felt it didn't outperform other delays (like the analog settings on an FB/FB4) and ended up returning or replacing it.