26% of 129 verified Apple AirPods 5owners don't recommend it — based on real owner comments from Reddit, enthusiast forums, and YouTube.
For balance: 65% recommend it. This page collects the complaints so you know what you're signing up for — read the full owner report for both sides. How we score
“I just got them, the bummer thing is the ANC being too strong I can't stand the pressure in my ears”— @captainsparrow1229 on YouTube
“I bought them but they do hurt my ear and the left one falls off . even when i was in bed my right one keep falling off that’s do anoying so I’m going to return them.”— @veronicaserrato9827 on YouTube
“Upgraded from AP2 - difficult to remove them from the case. Awkward”— @jaceknowicki on YouTube
“I just boght them and I dont know what to do with them... I though they are the same like the wired headphones which fit me perfectly and the sole reason I got these.”— @Rumen.Aleksandrov on YouTube
“i went from 3 to 5s and the battery life absolutely sucks! I feel like i have to charge them twice a day when i used to go multiple days between charges”— Ill_Knowledge_373 on r/airpods
“I bought the AirPods 5. As much as I tried to like them , I think my AirPods 4 have better midrange, less V shaped sound profile. I returned the AirPods 5 to Apple.”— @MrBMW503 on YouTube
“I had the same thought coming from AirPods 4. Did not live up to all the reviews I saw, sounded muddy especially bass, just everything was worse than the 4s”— BookkeeperTypical245 on r/airpods
“I returned them. I found them unremarkable and overly expensive for what they are. And five hours battery on these is wishful thinking. I was getting around 3 and I had the wireless charging case version.”— humbuckaroo on r/airpods
“Have encountered some prob with 5, like -A couple of times, my AirPods have made a crackling or popping sound at the exact moment an incoming call came in, instead of playing the normal ringtone.”— Stranger170299 on r/airpods
“Honestly the newer are ones are considerably worse in my opinion. The bass is very overbearing on every song and vocals sound muffled into the background.”— Frequent-Nothing-116 on r/airpods
“These fall right out of your ears every time. They also are NOT i repeat NOT compatible with the Ipod Touch. Save yourself the aggravation & irritation of returning them.”— @Hof79905 on YouTube
“I went from AirPods 2 to AirPods 5 and they are so painful after an hour of usage. I’m considering returning them. Also the bass seems way to overpowering even after adjusting EQ”— akakumo279 on r/airpods
Not complaints — practical notes from owners that didn't affect the score.
“The mic will get clogged over time. I’ve probably averaged a pair per year over that time. I’d be impressed to get 2 years out of pair. I expect to replace every 1-2 years.”— haxlife on r/airpods
“The 4s battery life is such trash though. The 5s anc magsafe are much better. A meaningful difference in battery life and swiping the stem to change volume are nice.”— TDA900 on r/airpods
“UPDATE: The Find My issue is fixed! My phone and iPad were not updated to the new iOS and a quick check in with Customer Service fixed the issue! Make sure if you buy these AirPods to update your phone✅”— Rare_Mortgage4052 on r/airpods
“Considering how much I don’t use my app2 noise canceling, I think the 5s are what I might pick up next. Plus, I just don’t like things pushing into my ear canals.”— Darkencypher on r/airpods
“have you checked the iOS settings? there is some hearing protection setting that (might) limit the loudness, default is 80db or 90db, i think. maybe that is why.”— Iidontknowjack on r/airpods
“Airpods Pro 3 fit my ears and sound great. Airpods 5 fit my right ear, but the left ear does not stay in place like the first gen airpods. The end.”— Zentrii on r/airpods
“UNLESS you have an Android phone because then you're not loosing anything with the base model. Not everybody lives in the Apple ecosystem bro.”— vanyethehun on r/airpods
“I always have a regular and a pro version. One for casual listening in the house and one for noice cancelling tasks like airplane or work. Got the 5s too. They are nice and small”— Atosl on r/airpods