“Don’t understand this pocket clip, why make it reversible when it’s tip up carry?”

72% of 61 verified owners recommend the Olight Baton 4, based on real owner verdicts aggregated from Reddit, enthusiast forums, and YouTube.
Affiliate blogs here say 100% recommend, while the owner-based score is 72%. They earn a commission on every sale — so we show them for transparency but never let them move the score.
The headline score reflects owners (Reddit, enthusiast forums), independent lab tests, blogs with no affiliate links, and YouTube owner-comments when they line up with owners. Affiliate blogs is shown for perspective but kept out here — hover the i for why.
Synthesized from what Olight Baton 4 owners say — not a spec sheet.
No, it runs on Olight's own 650mAh 3.6V lithium-ion cell, and owners who want to keep standard cells on hand count that against it. One owner bought it expecting to keep CR123A cells as a backup and found the supplied cell puts both contacts at the head, while another says the proprietary cells are why they stopped buying the brand. Olight's manual specifies only that cell.
Not with the plain Baton 4. Olight's manual lists the box as the flashlight, a USB magnetic charging cable and a pouch, while the 5000mAh case belongs to the Premium edition and is also sold on its own. The case is the part owners talk about warmly: Olight rates it at five full charges of the light and gives it a USB-C port for topping up a phone.
About a minute and a half. Olight's runtime chart holds Turbo at 1,300 lumens for roughly 1.5 minutes before the first step down, then steps again on the way out to about 73 minutes in total. The steady modes are what to plan around: 60 lumens for 8 hours, 12 lumens for 35 hours, and a 0.5 lumen moonlight rated at 30 days.
Tint is the other thing owners knock. Olight specifies a cool white emitter of 5700 to 7000K with a CRI of 70, and the owners who dislike the beam are blunt about it, calling it green. They sit against a clear majority who like the light as it is, which is why the score stays where it does.
Olight's figures are 63mm by 21mm and 52.5g with the cell in. Size is what owners carry it for, in a fifth pocket, clipped to a hat brim or stuck to a wheel arch by the magnetic tail, and 72% of 61 owners recommend it. The body is rated IPX8 and to a 1.5 meter drop.
A lifetime warranty on the flashlight itself. Olight's current policy lists flashlights as lifetime covered and the magnetic charging cable at one year, and applies to products bought in 2023 or later. Holsters, clips and lanyards carry no warranty at all. Buying through a third party sends a claim to that seller first, and Olight provides a prepaid return label only inside the first 30 days.
Retailers' own star averages, for comparison — separate from our vetted owner-verdict score above.
“Don’t understand this pocket clip, why make it reversible when it’s tip up carry?”
“This is the best light I've found.”
“as soon as you buy one, they'll come out with a better version”
“IMO a “tactical” tail switch is pointless unless it’s single press for turbo.”
“Having this case in my conex and charging it every once in a long while all while keeping my flashlight charged between shifts is awesome.”
“I bought two of these and BOTH of them stopped working after maybe a year”
“The proprietary cells are the main reason I will no longer purchase or recommend Olight to anyone.”
“Pretty sure mine started out disabled, because I accidentally left it on in my shop and discovered it the next morning completely run down.”
“So far I'm really liking the Baton 4!”
“Its a great light, but the comparison with the maglite is in my opinion a little bit apples and pears”
“I’d say anything over the baton is better. Unless you like green tint garbage.”
“absolutely love the new Baton 4 upgrades”
“this works great as a travel/bag light”
“The side switch is not clicky or tactile at all”
“I wish you could replace the battery in the charging case”
“This is the finest flashlight I have ever owned.”
“the price-quality-ratio is not correct”
“I have the Baton4! I love the looks of it. Just hate the lockout situation and the color of the light.”
“Idk why they didn't use an sft-40 in the Baton 4 pro.”
“the puke green is the baton 4”
“I haven’t broken one yet”
“Love it”
“I like the batons size but would prefer a usb C charging capability”
“it has been absolutely flawless”
Practical notes owners raise — setup, quirks, and issues to watch for. They don't say whether the person likes the product, so they're not counted in the score, but they inform the pros, cons, and who it's for.
“it's possible a majority of people prefer it that way”