Flashlights · owner-verdict comparison

Fenix PD36R Pro vs Olight Baton 4: what real owners say

Real owners rate these about evenly: 75% of 72 Fenix PD36R Pro owners recommend it, vs 72% of 61 for the Olight Baton 4.

Verdicts aggregated from Reddit, enthusiast forums, and YouTube owner comments — affiliate reviews excluded. Sample sizes differ; judge accordingly. How we score

Fenix PD36R Pro

75%of 72 owners recommend
75% recommend · 15% neutral · 10% don't
Owners praise
  • Very bright with long throw
  • Rugged build, survives drops and abuse
  • Good balance of flood and throw
Owners complain about
  • Too big and heavy for pocket EDC
  • Green tint and low CRI on lower modes
  • Dual tailswitch awkward with gloves
Full owner report →

Olight Baton 4

72%of 61 owners recommend
72% recommend · 17% neutral · 11% don't
Owners praise
  • Compact and tiny, ideal for EDC pocket or hat carry
  • A great light owners love
  • Bright, powerful output for its small size
Full owner report →

Which should you buy?

Get the Fenix PD36R Pro if
  • ✓Work and duty users wanting a rugged all-rounder
  • ✓Outdoors and dog-walkers needing throw and runtime
  • ✓People who prefer a simple two-button tailcap UI
Skip it if
  • Pocket-EDC minimalists who want compact size
  • Color-accuracy seekers put off by green tint
Get the Olight Baton 4 if
  • ✓Everyday carry users wanting a tiny pocket light
  • ✓Workers who clip it to a hat brim
  • ✓People wanting big output from a compact body
  • ✓Buyers who value the charging-case and magnetic base
Skip it if
  • Anyone wanting standard, non-proprietary batteries
  • Bargain hunters eyeing cheaper Wurkkos or Sofirn lights

What Fenix PD36R Pro owners say

“this is my all around favorite to use around the farm. Good flood and great spot for scanning the distance.”
— @JonBonynge on YouTube
“I have this light, it's fantastic”
— @agates9383 on YouTube
“I have the Pd36R Pro and find it useless for camping. Mode memory is not what I prefer as I never know what level it will come on at.”
— Spirited_Glass_7211 on Reddit

What Olight Baton 4 owners say

“This is the best light I've found.”
— @williamhulsey9209 on YouTube
“Having this case in my conex and charging it every once in a long while all while keeping my flashlight charged between shifts is awesome.”
— @Hook0403 on YouTube
“Don’t understand this pocket clip, why make it reversible when it’s tip up carry?”
— @churchsp on YouTube

Fenix PD36R Pro vs Olight Baton 4: frequently asked questions

Is the Fenix PD36R Pro or the Olight Baton 4 better?

Real owners rate these about evenly: 75% of 72 Fenix PD36R Pro owners recommend it, vs 72% of 61 for the Olight Baton 4.

Who should get the Fenix PD36R Pro?

Owners point the Fenix PD36R Pro at work and duty users wanting a rugged all-rounder, and outdoors and dog-walkers needing throw and runtime.

Who should get the Olight Baton 4?

Owners point the Olight Baton 4 at everyday carry users wanting a tiny pocket light, and workers who clip it to a hat brim.