Real owners rate these about evenly: 65% of 43 Herman Miller Aeron Size B owners recommend it, vs 66% of 41 for the Embody.
Verdicts aggregated from Reddit, enthusiast forums, and YouTube owner comments — affiliate reviews excluded. Sample sizes differ; judge accordingly. How we score
Owners mostly agree on which half of this chair works, which makes the disagreement easier to read than the split suggests. The back is the part nobody argues with: owners describe it shaping to the spine and holding support while they shift around, and the people who bought it for pain are the most positive voices here, several reporting none at all after years of trouble. The seat is the opposite story and collects nearly every complaint, whether that is a pan running short on depth, hard plastic where the legs rest, or padding that flattened inside two years of ten-hour days. Running underneath both is setup. A recurring group of owners say the chair felt odd when it arrived and only came right after they set back tension, back angle, and seat depth, with one fixing lower back pressure by dropping the seat height alone, while the owners who stayed unhappy are largely the ones for whom no adjustment helped. Price doubt is real but it is the minority position: a few call it overrated or say a cheaper Steelcase would have done the job, while most owners who spent the money describe it as the best thing they did for themselves. The sharpest dividing line is body size, since the suspended area is not large, and the owners who felt too big for it did not adapt to it, they sent it back.
“Reclining to meditate in this chair is amazing!”— @kylelangley8818 on YouTube
“The Aeron Remastered and the Classic are both really amazing. Cannot beat the recline and the adjustability of just about every aspect of what’s important for tasking or relaxing.”— @MichaelCConti on YouTube
“I wanted to love my HM Aeron (supplied by work), but in the end my $150 Covid Office Depot chair is way more comfortable. Chairs are such a personal item and brand/cost don’t guarantee comfort”— 2ChanceRescue on r/BuyItForLife
“I love my Embody. People complain it’s too expensive, but I spend more time sitting in that chair than anything else in my life. For something that I spend 40% of my life in, it’s worth $1200.”— cusehoops98 on Reddit
“I love mine, probably will never buy another chair again. The back support it provides for anyone who needs something a little more specialized is unmatched by anything else on the market.”— CilantroToothpaste on Reddit
“The chair itself is very very comfortable, but I always got pain in my upper back / shoulder area from sitting in it, I felt like I was too big for the chair to properly support me.”— Mrbritton3 on Reddit
Real owners rate these about evenly: 65% of 43 Herman Miller Aeron Size B owners recommend it, vs 66% of 41 for the Embody.
Owners point the Herman Miller Aeron Size B at all-day desk workers wanting posture and back support, and buyers seeking a decades-lasting, repairable chair.
Owners point the Embody at desk workers with ongoing back or sciatic pain who have already struck out with other chairs, and buyers willing to spend an hour on back tension, back angle, and seat depth before judging the chair.
The most-cited downside of the Herman Miller Aeron Size B is uncomfortable for some bodies despite the hype. For the Embody, it's it feels wrong out of the box, and for some owners no amount of adjustment ever fixes it..